5 Myths About Cold Process Soap
If you’ve ever picked up a bar of handmade cold process soap and thought, “Is this really that different from the stuff in the shops?” — you’re not alone. There are so many misconceptions about natural soap, especially cold process bars, and honestly, I believed a few of them myself before I started making them.
But the truth is, once you understand what goes into a cold process bar — and more importantly, what you don’t find in it — it’s hard to go back.
Let’s gently clear up some of the myths you might’ve heard, and give you the honest truth about what makes cold process soap so worth it.
Myth 1: It’s too harsh for sensitive skin
The truth: Cold process soap is actually one of the gentlest ways to cleanse — when it’s made properly.
The harshness you may associate with bar soap usually comes from commercial soap substitutes that are more detergent than soap. Cold process bars, on the other hand, are made with nourishing plant oils and butters, and they retain natural glycerin — a humectant that draws moisture to the skin.
If your skin feels dry or tight after washing, it might not be the water — it could be your soap.
Myth 2: It’s just a fancier version of store-bought soap
The truth: Most commercial “soap” isn’t actually soap at all.
Those supermarket bars are often syndet bars (synthetic detergent bars), made with foaming agents and filler ingredients designed for shelf life, not skin health. Cold process soap is made from scratch using oils and lye in a traditional method that creates a naturally cleansing, skin-supportive bar — no detergents, no shortcuts.
And while the process takes longer (up to 6 weeks of curing), it’s that slow, careful method that gives the bar its richness and gentle feel.
Myth 3: It melts too quickly in the shower
The truth: It will last — if you care for it the right way.
Yes, cold process bars are softer than commercial ones, but that’s because they’re not packed with hardening agents. The key is letting the bar dry between uses. Use a soap dish that drains, keep it out of direct water flow, and cut the bar in half if you want it to last even longer.
You’ll be surprised how many uses you can get out of a well-cared-for bar.
Myth 4: It’s only for people who love all-natural everything
The truth: Cold process soap is for anyone who wants their skin to feel soft, balanced, and nourished.
Even if you don’t consider yourself a natural skincare person, this isn’t about trends or labels. It’s about what your skin needs — and cold process bars do a beautiful job of cleansing without stripping. Plus, they often work better for people with eczema, dry patches, or sensitivity than many high-street “gentle” washes.
No lifestyle required — just skin that likes to feel calm and cared for.
Myth 5: It’s a luxury, not a daily essential
The truth: Once you try it, it’ll become part of your everyday ritual.
Cold process soap turns a simple moment — washing your hands, cleansing your face, stepping into the shower — into something that feels intentional. It’s not just about being clean. It’s about how your skin feels after and how you feel while using it.
The aromatherapy blends, the creamy lather, the way it softens the skin — these little details add up to something that makes everyday life feel a bit more grounded.
If you’ve been unsure about making the switch, I hope this gives you a gentle nudge. Cold process soap isn’t just handmade — it’s made to care for your skin.
Explore our natural soap collection and discover your new favourite ritual.